Italy’s negotiated settlement works, but only for those who move early

Italy’s negotiated settlement works, but only for those who move early



Filings for composizione negoziata, Italy’s confidential out-of-court negotiated settlement procedure run with an independent expert, have more than tripled in the country’s North-East. Regional daily il Nord Est reported the figures on 22 October, citing the Unioncamere observatory (Unioncamere is the association of Italian chambers of commerce) [1]: filings in Veneto went from 132 at 15 May 2024 to 252 a year later and 413 at 15 May 2026, a figure that matches Unioncamere’s half-year report [4]. Across the North-East they rose from 164 to 520. Nationally, 4,489 filings had been made by 15 May 2026 since the procedure started in November 2021 [4], and 4,853 by 1 July according to data Unioncamere previewed in July [3]. What matters to anyone running or financing a company under strain is a different number: how many of these procedures end well, and why.

One in five ends in a turnaround, and timing makes the difference

Unioncamere counts 594 procedures closed with a positive outcome at 15 May 2026, 21% of the 2,847 closed cases and double the figure of a year earlier; the Q1 2026 success rate was 20.2% [4]. A preliminary Q2 figure reported by BeBankers rises to 28.2% [3]. Companies that succeeded had on average 66 employees and EUR 32m of assets, against 39 and EUR 14m for those that failed [4]. Practitioners quoted in the local press say what anyone working on distressed cases sees constantly: the tool works when the company gets there in time. It is designed for a business whose imbalance makes a crisis likely but which can still be turned around; a company arriving with no cash has neither the time nor the credibility to negotiate.

A stay buys time; the plan creates value

One figure deserves attention: 83% of applicants request protective measures (a stay on creditor action) and 55% suspensive measures, but only 19% declare a need for new financing [4]. A stay stops creditors; it creates no value. Unless the months of protection produce a credible plan, a cash forecast that holds and funding for the negotiation period, the time runs out. A plausible reading, not the report’s, is that many companies enter without an answer to the liquidity question. The 2023 ministerial guidelines tell the expert how to assess the plan and run negotiations [5]; a company that arrives with reconciled numbers and explicit assumptions makes that process faster and its proposal to creditors more credible.

How owners, CFOs and banks should act

Owners and CFOs should watch five signals and treat them as a threshold for attention rather than an emergency: recurring stress in a 13-week cash forecast; arrears to suppliers, tax or social security lengthening month after month; twelve-month debt service not covered by projected cash flow; overdrafts, line cancellations or repayment demands from banks; covenants at risk at the next test date. When two or three appear together, the question is not whether to file but whether the business can be turned around and which combination of operating, financial and perimeter measures that requires. The CFO should reach that point with two documents already in hand: a reliable weekly cash forecast and a first version of the plan with stated assumptions. Building them takes a few weeks, and doing it before the filing is worth far more than doing it during.

For lenders the logic is the mirror image: if outcomes are better early, spotting imbalances early and pushing the borrower to act serves the creditor as much as the debtor. That is when a standstill, super-senior new money and security can be agreed on reasonable terms. The procedure has a limited duration and protective measures expire, so data, plan and first conversations with core lenders belong before the filing. The data say that companies which use the tool early and with a plan have a fair chance of coming through. That window of time is the most valuable resource a company under strain has, and it should be used before it closes.

Sources

  1. 1.il Nord Est, N. Brillo, “Imprese in crisi, domande triplicate per la composizione negoziata in Fvg”, 22 ottobre 2026.
  2. https://www.ilnordest.it/economia/imprese/imprese-in-crisi-domande-triplicate-per-la-composizione-
  3. negoziata-in-fvg-awq1aelz
  4. 2.Corriere dell’Economia, “Crisi d’impresa, in Veneto triplicate le richieste di composizione negoziata”, 25 ottobre
  5. 2026 (consultato il solo titolo). https://www.corrieredelleconomia.it/2026/10/25/crisi-dimpresa-in-veneto-
  6. triplicate-le-richieste-di-composizione-negoziata/
  7. 3.BeBankers, “Composizione negoziata: in aumento le percentuali di successo nel secondo trimestre 2026, dice
  8. Unioncamere”, 13 luglio 2026. https://www.bebankers.it/composizione-negoziata-in-aumento-le-percentuali-
  9. di-successo-nel-secondo-trimestre-2026-dice-unioncamere/
  10. 4.Unioncamere, “La composizione negoziata della crisi d’impresa. Rapporto semestrale, IX edizione”, dati al 15
  11. maggio 2026, pubblicato giugno 2026. https://www.unioncamere.gov.it/sites/default/files/articoli/2026-
  12. 06/Rapporto%20semestrale%20IX%20edizione%20maggio%202026.pdf
  13. 5.EC News, S. Mansoldo, “Principio di competitività nella selezione dell’acquirente nel trasferimento d’azienda nella
  14. composizione negoziata”, 10 giugno 2025. https://www.ecnews.it/legale/societa-e-crisi-di-impresa/crisi-
  15. impresa/principio-competitivita-nella-selezione-dellacquirente-nel-trasferimento-dazienda-nella-
  16. composizione-negoziata/

Edited by:
Fabio Trabucchi
Marco Zorzetto




20/11/2026